Judge Konrad von Finkenstein is being toasted and roasted today. The Judge just ruled that Canadians who make music files available for sharing over the Internet are not necessarily commiting an illegal act. That's how I read some reports of his ruling.
I think the larger issue is not whether its legal or illegal. The larger issue is that how music has been distributed traditionally does not work for a huge mass of people. And the recording industry, if it is not to die in its present form, needs to recognize this...like yesterday.
I also think for pay legal music download sites are going to thrive, despite this Canadian ruling. Sites like Puretracks and itunes are giving people music how they want it, with no moral or legal issues to worry about.
I do wish there was an easy centralized online place that would let you know which artist was represented by which for pay service. Would make things a lot easier